“Everybody's Got Monsters” .................................Company
“Half of a Life”............................................................ Samantha 
“ Old Friends”..............................................................Apathy & Samantha
“What's the Point?” .................................................Apathy & Samantha
“Be Afraid”.................................................................... Fear, Samantha & Apathy
“You Don't Want to Know” ................................... Fear, Samantha & Apathy
“All Downhill From Here”........................................ Body
“Dress Up” ..................................................................... Body, Samantha, Fear & Apathy
“Don't Open the Box”................................................. Fear, Body, Apathy, Mother & Samantha
“Happy Birthday Baby” ............................................Birthday Girl 
 “The Next Part”.......................................................... Samantha, Birthday Girl, Mother &  Company 
 “Everybody's Got Monsters”  (Reprise) .............Samantha, Fear, Body, Apathy & Birthday Girl
“Phobias” .......................................................................Birthday Girl, Samantha, Mother & Company
“That's What I Would Do”........................................ Samantha
“You Need Us!”............................................................. Body, Fear, Apathy, Samantha & Birthday Girl "Finale” ............................................................................Company